top of page

The Democratization of DAFs

Oct 28
8 min read

By Sari McConnell, CFRE, MBA


Donor Boom’s Founder and CEO, Sari McConnell, had her article, “The Democratization of DAFs,” published in the October 2026 issue of Advancing Philanthropy, the Association of Fundraising Professionals (AFP Global ) quarterly magazine distributed to over 30,000 fundraising professionals. This is the second article that AFP Global has published this year about her Generosity Guide Framework™. 


Read the full article below!





The Democratization of DAFs


Donor Advised Funds Have a Reputation Problem


  • They're a parking lot for wealthy donors who want a tax break.

  • They're the darling of bad press — criticized for having no required payout rules and trustees who can block donor grant requests to charities under investigation.

  • They're elitist, only something high-net-worth individuals have access to through their wealth managers.


So what if I told you that one of the best things you can do as a nonprofit fundraiser is to open one yourself?


In the past few years, the DAF marketplace has quietly matured into a robust landscape that is accessible to every intentional donor, not just the wealthy ones. They serve donors like you and me.


Don’t believe me? Today, you can open a DAF with one of the most recognizable online providers for $36 a year, which allows you to grant as little as $18 to the nonprofit of your choice. No minimum deposit required to open. And this provider competes with several others who offer similarly low barriers to entry.


Of course, there are other DAF options out there that have higher investment thresholds and fees, but also come with a higher level of service to the user. Community foundations can help you direct DAFs to local high school scholarship funds. Religiously affiliated institutions can help you navigate the options using specific criteria. Financial institutions might bundle it with your brokerage account advisory services competitively priced.



Top 3 Benefits of DAF Giving



Here are the benefits to your donors. A DAF (1) organizes a donor’s charitable giving history in one dedicated place so that it can be viewed strategically year over year; (2) minimizes the tax-time paperwork associated with charitable giving; (3) creates a place where a donor can manage their charitable giving with as much thought and care as a retirement account.


And I haven't even mentioned the tax benefit potential yet.


My point is, we are witnessing the democratization of the DAF before our very eyes. This is of enormous benefit to professional fundraisers, if we know how to play it.


I bring this to your attention, as a fellow fundraiser, because we don’t have an intimate relationship with DAF giving. A DAF check doesn’t give us the same instant gratification as a credit card donation, does it? Our Ways to Give page includes the option and increasingly so does our gala fund-a-need verbiage, but it’s not an active part of the donor conversation. Certainly not one-on-one. We all have the shared experience of giving by credit card to our favorite organizations. Most of us can't say the same about giving by DAF — and that unfamiliarity is exactly what makes it feel foreign and unconversational as fundraisers.


Sure, the donor-advised fund has a few warts. However, if we are serious about putting our nonprofits on a path to 5x revenue growth — and Dr. Russell James's research makes plain that wealth giving is exactly how we get there — I say we bet on this frog and jump in with both feet.



Why Wealth Giving Is Good for Nonprofits



Texas Tech University Professor Dr. Russell James' research on 1 million+ nonprofit tax returns shows that nonprofits accepting non-cash gifts grow up to six times faster than those that don't. A DAF is a non-cash, wealth-giving vehicle by definition. When donors move these funds out of the noisy checking account competing for the mortgage, the car payment, and the piano lessons and move them into a quieter arena where funds are earmarked for charitable giving, that’s a donor we want for life! The donor has made their choice: these funds are mission-bound. That shifts the whole game.


That’s why we fundraisers should be initiating the conversation about opening and strategically using a donor-advised fund rather than keeping the DAF conversation at arm’s length. If we want to set our nonprofit on the path to 6x growth, we should be embracing the DAF and our donor in a big bear hug.


We’re missing a brilliant opportunity.



Enter the Generosity Guide


This is a fundamental shift in how we engage with donors — and it calls for an expanded vision of what a fundraiser can be. I call it being a Generosity Guide. A Generosity Guide is a professional fundraiser, who ignites generosity by helping donors navigate tax-smart giving options and bridge the gap between donors and their financial advisors.


The DAF is a great example of tax-smart giving. However, we tend to sidestep the conversation and leave this work to tax experts and financial advisors. Or we view this as a planned giving conversation best left to the fundraising specialists.


What I’m talking about is annual campaign conversations that you could be initiating with your major donors who are not giving as tax-efficiently as they could be. The new tax provisions in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) are about to pinch the tax deductibility of those generous gifts your donors make if they itemize their taxes. Who better than you to suggest that they consider opening up a donor-advised fund? By initiating the conversation, you create a fantastic opportunity to deepen your relationship with your donor by signaling your interest in their welfare. You also dramatically increase both the likelihood that they will open one and that those funds will be earmarked for your organization.



How to Convert Donors to Wealth Giving



Dr. James' research lights the way. Now we must blaze our own path on HOW to get donors to change how they give.


The DAF conversation is the friendly little engine that can get you up the hill. And once your donors start giving from wealth, they are literally giving you the toot-toot! that they have both the capacity and the desire to give significantly more.



The Birth of a DAF Nation

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), signed under Trump’s first administration, took effect in 2018. The TCJA increased the standard deduction from $6,500 to $12,000 for single filers, and from $13,000 to $24,000 for joint filers — nearly doubling it.


Every year, taxpayers choose between taking the standard deduction or itemizing, whichever results in a bigger tax break. Nearly doubling the standard deduction had a dramatic impact on itemizing: in 2017, 30.6% of filers itemized deductions. By 2022, only 9.5% did. Therefore, it’s no surprise that the percentage of donors who took a charitable deduction dropped from 24.8% of filers to just 7.5%.


Nearly two-thirds of donors who were previously deducting their charitable gifts lost that benefit overnight. This is where the DAF market began its massive expansion.


When the Trump-era TCJA pushed millions of donors out of itemization, the DAF emerged as the workaround — donors could front-load contributions in a single year to help qualify for the itemizing path, take the tax deduction up front, then grant it out over time.



DAFs Are About to Get Huge


Now imagine the DAF on steroids. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), which primarily took effect this year makes it a must-have for intentional donors. Why? Not only did it make the higher standard deduction (now $16,100 single / $32,200 married filing jointly) permanent, replacing the sunset clause set to expire in 2025. It takes a new big pinch out of the tax deductibility of charitable gifts for those itemizing, the very donors most likely to be your major donors. It restricts itemizing donors from receiving a tax deduction for charitable giving for amounts that exceed .5% of a household’s adjusted gross income each year. For an itemizing household making $400,000, the first $2000 of charitable giving they give to nonprofits is not tax-deductible every year — $8,000 over four years.


This is a huge loss.


DAF “bunching” dramatically offsets this .5% loss every year. Contribute four years of giving upfront, take the tax deduction once, and get dinged .5% that one time instead of four.


Side note: Thanks to the strong, sustained advocacy work by AFP Global and other nonprofit organizations, OBBBA gives a new above-the-line charitable deduction to donors taking the standard deduction, up to $1000 for single filers, or $2000 if married filing jointly. However, this complicates matters further for donors who are likely unaware or just plain confused.



Donors Need Help. They need a Generosity Guide.


The DAF market has matured and the perception that DAFs are for the wealthy is outdated. DAF giving is on the rise, with donors using DAFs to give $64.89 billion to charities in 2024 — a 19% increase year over year.


With OBBBA in play, fundraisers who help their donors navigate these choppy waters are putting their nonprofits on the road to increasing their fundraising revenue sixfold. If you become a Generosity Guide, it will be solving the HOW question when looking to convert donors from disposable income to wealth.



Generosity Guides Lead by Example



Additionally, initiating the conversation will deepen your relationship with your donors. “You’ve been so generous to our organization that I thought you might like to know that more of our donors are starting to use a DAF to donate more tax-efficiently. Have you ever considered opening one?” Think your donor would respond positively to your interest in their financial welfare? I do.


Walking donors through the DAF giving experience moves them from reactive year-end givers to strategic, intentional ones — the kind of donor behavior you wish every donor on your list had. They’ll be more consistent with the amount and timing of their gifts, and more generous, too.


And remember, you’re not a tax advisor or financial expert. Your job as a Generosity Guide is to be familiar with the basics and arm your donors with the right questions and the motivation to initiate a follow up conversation with those advisors.



Let’s Talk about DAF’s Bad Rap


DAF dollars that sit undistributed are a legitimate concern for the sector. Taking a more active role in talking about DAF giving with donors can only improve this situation. And it’s still part of our job – we have to ask for the donation. Once you know your donor is giving from their DAF – and of course you know this by properly documenting the gift type in your database – you can engage your donor in a conversation about it. “Did you know there are a lot of new tax benefits associated with using your DAF? Let me walk you through it.” As a Generosity Guide, that’s how you get DAF funds distributed. Ask for it by name.


DAF providers have been in the news for blocking donor grant requests to charities under investigation. This may be the case for a handful of nonprofits in this situation that are making the news, but there are more than 1.5 million 501(c)(3) organizations, according to IRS data. The story served as a reminder that funds in a DAF are no longer under a donor’s direct control (which is why you get a tax deduction) and are granted at the discretion of the financial institution holding them. It only made headlines, in my opinion, because it’s rare.


DAFs are perceived as elitist, but now that you’ve read this article, I hope you prove this wrong by opening up your own donor-advised fund today. As of 2024, you have 1,512 DAF providers in the U.S. to choose from.



Change Behavior. Start with Yourself.


My firm Donor Boom has surveyed the DAF market extensively. I can confidently tell you that there’s a DAF for every intentional donor.


Honestly, the hardest thing about using a DAF is changing one’s giving behavior. Once donors start using it, they’re going to love it, and your organization for suggesting it.

And then, as a newly minted Generosity Guide, you'll get on the path to growing your fundraising revenue six times over by being able to speak from experience. You’ll have one of the most natural conversation openers in fundraising: "I recently opened a DAF for my own charitable giving. Have you ever thought about doing the same?"


Sari McConnell (CFRE, MBA) is the founder of Donor Boom, a data-driven strategic fundraising firm that helps nonprofits grow their revenue. She is writing a book on how to become a Generosity Guide because she believes you can become one, too. Sari is not a tax advisor or financial professional. Request her DAF Provider Market Survey at: www.donorboom.com.


Want to learn more about growing major gifts through tax-smart giving?

Explore Donor Boom's Generosity Guide Framework™  for Major Gift Growth to discover how nonprofits can help donors move from giving disposable income to giving from wealth.


------------------------------------------------------------------

Originally published in the October 2026 issue of Advancing Philanthropy.



Comments


Subscribe to Donor Boom's newsletter and

receive a free DAF Providers Comparison Sheet.  

©2021 Donor Boom. All rights reserved.

Donor Boom
  • LinkedIn
  • Donor Boom YouTube Channel
Capital Campaign Toolkit
WBE_Seal_RGB-700x397.png
CFRE Certified Fundraising Executive

GOLD SPONSOR

AFP GG Logo .png

sari@donorboom.com Burlingame, CA 94010​

bottom of page